What makes a top Super Bowl commercial in the perspective of the advertiser?…Certainly increasing brand awareness is a goal, but for others the goal could be to create an informative commercial. Maybe for another advertiser, the primary metric is how controversial the ad is and or, how much viral buzz is generated from that controversial commercial. Two things that all advertisers do care about are the Super Bowl commercial’s return on ad spend (ROAS) – they need to recoup the cost of their 30 second, $3M ad spend and the Super Bowl’s audience reach and life-time value. Nielsen has recently announced that Super Bowl 44 is the most watched Super Bowl ever with 106.6M views on television alone.
When determining an ad’s reach and life-time value, analysts must now factor internet activity into this data, on top of television viewership. This data can include query search volume, standard web analytics & e-commerce measures, and now even social media metrics such as blog posts, comments, retweets, status mentions, sentiment, video views, bookmarks, diggs, etc. etc. Taking this into consideration we thought it may be interesting to compare the five brands who created the top Super Bowl commercials of 2010 across a few of these metrics. We considered these brands to be (in no order); Denny’s (Free Grand Slam Breakfast campaign), Dockers (Free Pants campaign), Doritos (Get Yo Hands Off My Mamma et al.) Bud Light (Bud Light House et al.) and GoDaddy (Danica Patrick & the GoDaddy Girls campaign).
Top Super Bowl Commercials: Google Search Volume
Using Google Insights we determined that Doritos and Dockers were the brands that saw the biggest spike in search volume over after their Super Bowl commercials were aired. GoDaddy, Denny’s and Bud Light closed out the top five. One interesting point to note is that on Tuesday February 8th while Doritos, Dockers, GoDaddy and Bud Light traffic began to trough, Denny’s was still on the rise. It is important to note that Tuesday, February 8th was also the day that Denny’s was offering their free grand slam breakfast.




Top Super Bowl Commercials: Domain Traffic

A metric that our advertisers were certainly looking at were the impact of the Super Bowl commercials on direct load sessions and unique visitors to their own domains. Using Alexa.com as our source it is clear that Dockers.com experienced the highest increase in terms of reach from their Super Bowl commercial and free pants campaign. Dockers.com saw a 7-day traffic spike of 1,350%, that is incredible! Now the only questions that remains are did that traffic convert and how many new customers were generated?

Dennys.com also saw a 400% increase in reach over the past 7-days and keeping with the trend of Google Searches and Twitter mentions, that number has continued to grow after the few days following the Super Bowl.

Doritos in collaboration with the NFL had launched a site called CrashTheSuperBowl.com back in 2006 as a user-generated commercial voting site. The site has seen a 90% increase in reach over the past 7-days. GoDaddy.com also showed a marginal 7% increase in its 7-day reach as according to Alexa.
Top Super Bowl Commercials on YouTube
So we know 106.6 million people watched Super Bowl 44, but how many tuned in after the Super Bowl to check out their favorite 2010 Super Bowl commercials? The short answer is, a lot. Doritos Super Bowl Commercial Channel, CrashTheSuperBowl, is the fourth most watched channel on YouTube this week with over 3.675 million views. Their channel also has 3,818 subscribers and the most watched video (Get Yo Hands Off My Mamma), alone has 1.718 million views, 2,805 comments, and 4,454 ratings (5-star overall) as of writing this post. The Bud Light Channel, OfficialBudLight, was the fifteenth most watched channel on YouTube this week with 1.385 million views. Not surprisingly, GoDaddy.com has also seen a increase in their GoDaddyTV channel views as it is currently the seventy-third most watched channel on YouTube this week. An un-official Denny’s channel, Denny’s SuperBowl, has generated over 1.148 million views since it’s creation on January 29th, 2009.
Top Super Bowl Commercials on Twitter

So just what commercial generated the most interest to users on Twitter? According to Trendistic, Doritos was the champion in terms of the amount of mentions in a given time. In the 6 pm EST hour during the Super Bowl, “Doritos” was mentioned in 1.2% of the all tracked tweets.
Dockers and Denny’s each maxed out at .23% and .16%. Again in the graphs below, you will see that Denny’s appeared to of had the larger life-span but that is skewed because of their Grand Slam offering on February 8th.

